Gray-haired man holding a kettlebell at the top of a swing in a warm-lit gym.

Benefits of Combining Cardio and Strength Training: What Studies Show

Combining cardio and strength training can develop both fitness and strength. Compare trial benefits, body-composition changes and mortality associations without a lifespan promise.

The benefits of combining cardio and strength training depend on which outcome you mean. This guide separates fitness, body composition, risk markers and mortality associations before considering what the findings can tell you.

A stronger leg press, a change in body fat and a lower mortality hazard are not interchangeable results. Understanding which outcome a study measured makes the case for both types of training more useful and more realistic.

What does combining cardio and strength training add?

Cardio develops the ability to sustain aerobic effort, while strength training challenges muscles against resistance. Including both gives a program two kinds of work instead of expecting one activity to cover every goal.

Start with the outcome rather than the workout label. The table below maps four questions to the comparison or measurement needed to answer them.

Benefits of combining training: what the evidence actually measured
Potential benefit Relevant finding Limit to keep in mind
CardioRACE fitness/strength Combined improved VO2peak and chest/leg-press strength versus control. Resistance-only strength gains larger.
Risk composite Aerobic/combined improved versus control; resistance-only nonsignificant. Not event prevention.
Body composition All exercise groups reduced body-fat percentage versus control. No unique combined advantage.
Long-term survival association Use the common-reference estimates below. Check association, comparator and uncertainty.

Keep the comparison attached to each result. Your goals, abilities and restrictions determine which questions to take into a planning discussion.

Fitness and strength: what was compared?

CardioRACE randomized 406 adults, 35 to 70, with overweight/obesity and elevated blood pressure to aerobic, resistance, combined or control for one year.

Exercise entailed three supervised 60-minute sessions weekly; combined sessions used 5 minutes warm-up, 25 resistance, 25 aerobic and 5 cooldown. All received DASH education; established cardiovascular disease was excluded.

These research conditions are not a personal loading prescription.

Cardiovascular risk: read the composite

The composite averaged systolic blood pressure, LDL, fasting glucose and body-fat percentage. Aerobic-versus-combined composite and fitness differences were nonsignificant, not proof of equivalence.

A composite is a summary of selected measurements, not a record of prevented heart attacks, strokes or deaths. An improved summary does not establish that every component or every person improved.

Body composition: distinguish the measurements

Combined body fat fell 1 percentage point versus control; other component contrasts were nonsignificant. Resistance-only lean mass increased versus control; the combined change was nonsignificant.

A percentage point of body fat is different from a percentage of body weight. Strength, lean mass, fat percentage and scale weight are separate measurements, so one result cannot stand in for all four.

Mortality: read the reference group

Zhao and colleagues linked 479,856 US adults’ baseline leisure-activity surveys to death records: 59,819 deaths; median follow-up 8.75 years.

One cohort, one reference group: Zhao et al., BMJ 2020
Reported activity category Participants Adjusted mortality hazard ratio
Below both study thresholds 268,193 1.00, reference
Strengthening threshold only 21,428 0.89, 95% confidence interval 0.85 to 0.94
Aerobic threshold only 113,851 0.71, 95% confidence interval 0.69 to 0.72
Both thresholds 76,384 0.60, 95% confidence interval 0.57 to 0.62

Thresholds: 150 light-to-moderate or 75 vigorous minutes/equivalent weekly, plus strengthening twice weekly. Below both is not no exercise; “only” still allows some of the other activity.

HR 0.60 denotes 40% lower adjusted hazard, not lifespan or individual probability. Baseline self-report, changing habits, confounding, reverse causation and unmeasured nonleisure activity limit causal predictions.

Subtracting estimates cannot isolate adding strength at an unchanged cardio dose for the same person.

What these benefits mean for your own training

A useful way to apply the evidence is to distinguish the activity you do from the outcome you want to improve. This prevents a calorie estimate or a busy workout calendar from standing in for every aspect of progress.

Two women reviewing an open notebook on a gym bench near dumbbells and stationary bikes.
Illustrative image: recording aerobic activity and strength work separately can clarify what a program includes.
A simple benefits check: activity, performance and health
What to distinguish A useful record or question What it cannot tell you
Training exposure Record aerobic minutes and intensity separately from strengthening days and the muscle groups worked. A packed calendar does not prove a specific physiological benefit.
Performance Within an appropriate existing program, compare like-for-like tasks: the same route or the same exercise under similar conditions. One easier walk or heavier lift is not a clinical heart-health test.
Clinical health Discuss relevant blood pressure, blood tests and medical limits with your healthcare professional. Improved gym performance does not establish that medication or follow-up is unnecessary.

This is an editorial checklist for interpreting progress, not a validated risk score or a diagnostic test. It keeps several possible benefits visible without turning them into a promise.

The CDC’s general adult guidance includes at least 150 minutes of moderate aerobic activity or 75 minutes of vigorous activity, or an equivalent mix, plus strengthening on at least two days covering all major muscle groups. Some activity is better than none, and the aerobic time can be broken into smaller amounts.

These are general weekly targets, not instructions to jump immediately from inactivity to a research protocol. For a counted example week and the practical question of combining sessions, see our guide to combining cardio and strength training.

If a medical condition, injury or ongoing pain affects activity, ask a qualified healthcare professional about appropriate types and amounts. Neither a cohort hazard ratio nor a supervised trial overrides individual restrictions.

Do you need HIIT to get these benefits?

Neither design establishes HIIT as necessary.

A claim that a particular interval workout is essential needs a comparison of that protocol with an appropriate alternative. A workout label alone does not identify what was assigned, recorded or measured.

Is combining training always better than choosing one?

Use the same outcome and comparator when judging “better.” A stronger lift, a body-fat measurement and a risk-factor score answer different questions.

The practical checklist above keeps those questions visible. Use it to describe your goal and uncertainty without treating a research result as a personal forecast.

Sources

Medical disclaimer: This article provides general fitness and health information, not medical advice or an individualized exercise or nutrition plan. If you have an injury, ongoing pain or a medical condition, ask a qualified healthcare professional which activities and dietary changes are appropriate for you.

Share your love
Chris Pruitt, certified personal trainer and WorkoutHealthy founder
Chris Pruitt

Chris Pruitt is a certified ASFA personal trainer and the founder of WorkoutHealthy, a fitness equipment retailer serving customers since 2007. He has more than 16 years in the fitness business, and he writes and fact checks everything published on Insider.

The Insider Five

Five stories worth your time, every Friday. One email a week, no pitches.