Training specificity becomes easier to discuss when you separate what someone practised from what their assessment actually measured. A faster time, a heavier setting and a higher score can each answer a useful question, but the question depends on the task.
The three training specificity examples below use fictional records to show that distinction. They are comparisons to interpret, not workouts, performance targets or tests to perform.
Start with the question the result needs to answer
“I want to improve at running” leaves several possible questions open. Completing a particular route, recording a time for that route and preparing for a different event are different outcomes to describe.
Write the question before choosing the number: “Did this person complete this route more quickly under comparable conditions?” is narrower than “Did their overall fitness improve?” A result that answers the first question does not contain every measurement needed for the second.
This distinction also helps when reading someone else’s training story. Identify the activity they practised, the task used for assessment and the outcome reported before borrowing their conclusion.
Separate practice, assessment and the intended goal
Use three separate descriptions: the practice activity, the assessment task and the goal outside that assessment. They may overlap, but writing them separately makes a proposed connection visible.
For example, “practised on an indoor cycle,” “completed a running route” and “wants to finish a particular walking event” describe three tasks. Their relationship needs an explanation; the word “cardio” alone does not supply the missing observations.
This is a way to examine a claim, rather than a rule that every practice session must reproduce an event. Supporting activities can have their own purposes, which should be named instead of being treated as measured success at every other task.
When a coach suggests an activity, ask what it is intended to help and how that purpose will be assessed. “What would this result still leave unknown?” is a useful follow-up.
What a progression review contributes
Kraemer and Ratamess’s 2004 resistance-training review describes progression as a process involving individual needs, target goals and evaluation. Its abstract discusses exercise selection and order, rest, sets, repetitions and intensity, with prescriptions varied over time to maintain or advance specific goals.
That is a framework for considering several variables, rather than a personal schedule. The abstract does not establish a compulsory weekly increase, a particular stall deadline or a fixed interval for lighter weeks.
For a broader discussion of strength-training principles, see our guide to what exercise scientists agree on. Here, the narrower question is whether a reported result actually measures the task being discussed.
Running example: two routes and one faster time
Imagine a runner records 30 minutes on Route A and 28 minutes on Route B. Both entries say “run,” but the second time alone does not show a two-minute improvement on Route A.
The record needs the route and distance before the comparison even refers to the same task. Terrain, conditions, timing method and the instructions for the attempt are additional details to describe rather than assume away.
| Available record | What it describes | What remains unresolved |
|---|---|---|
| Route A: 30 minutes; Route B: 28 minutes | Two recorded completion times for differently named routes | A repeat result on Route A and the details needed to compare conditions |
| Route A recorded twice using the same stated timing method | A comparison within the named route and method | Whether other conditions changed and what the result says about a different route or event |
Even a carefully described comparison is not an experiment that isolates the cause of a change. A timing record does not, by itself, identify which practice activity produced the result.
If the eventual goal is another route, keep that goal in a separate line. Describe preparation for it as a proposed connection, rather than relabelling the first route’s time as an observed result on the second.
Lifting example: different exercises with similar numbers
Now imagine a record changes from “machine press, setting 40” to “dumbbell press, 20 in each hand.” Adding the two dumbbell numbers produces 40 arithmetically, but does not establish that the two exercise tasks are equivalent.
The exercise names and the meaning of the quantities differ. The record should identify the equipment, units, whether the entry is per hand or total, and the stated movement and assistance conditions.
A second comparison might use the same exercise name while changing the range of motion or adding assistance. Keep those changes visible instead of presenting the larger number as though the task description stayed fixed.
This does not make either exercise a bad choice. It means the available entries cannot, on their own, answer a same-task improvement question or prove transfer to another lift.
A coach can explain the purpose of a variation and which outcome would count as evidence for that purpose. That conversation is different from assuming that a shared movement label makes every result interchangeable.
Skill example: check the denominator and the conditions
Consider a fictional accuracy record: seven successful attempts out of ten, followed by fourteen out of twenty. The second entry contains twice as many successes, but both proportions are 70 percent.
The larger count answers a different question from the success proportion. Neither number identifies the target size, distance, rules or assistance used during the attempts.
If the target becomes smaller between records, retain that detail beside the score. Do not silently treat the new task as the old one, or assume that an unchanged percentage means nothing changed.
The arithmetic is only an illustration of how to read a record. It does not validate an accuracy test, estimate measurement error or establish an appropriate number of attempts for a sport.
Apply the same distinction to a published demonstration: count, proportion and task conditions need separate descriptions. A carefully presented example still needs evidence before it can support a broader performance claim.
What a specificity review contributes
Reilly, Morris and Whyte’s 2009 review examines training specificity across aerobic, team and racket sports, strength and power activities, and cross-training and concurrent training. Its abstract also considers physiological assessment in elite athletes, including the need for valid, reliable and sensitive assessments.
The authors discuss a tension between laboratory reliability and resemblance to sporting demands, alongside field methods and sport-specific ergometers. This review abstract does not report a trial proving the transfer of the fictional activities above or prescribe a personal training dose.
The examples here are editorial comparisons, not results extracted from either review. They make missing information visible without assigning an effect size or claiming that one practice method outperforms another.
Check the comparison before changing the explanation
A result can be accurately recorded while the explanation attached to it goes further than the record allows. Check the task description before concluding that a programme succeeded, failed or needs a particular adjustment.
Also separate an observation from its proposed cause. “The score changed” and “this practice caused the change” require different support, even when they appear together in a convincing training story.
Two people’s different scores do not identify the reason for the difference. The scores alone cannot diagnose a hormonal issue, establish a genetic explanation or determine whether either person needs a medical evaluation.
A training partner can help check what was written down or point out an omitted task detail. That assistance does not turn an informal comparison into a controlled study or a clinical assessment.
Keep personal and clinical decisions separate
If an injury, ongoing pain or a medical condition affects your training, discuss changes with a doctor or physical therapist. Do not use a fictional comparison or someone else’s result as clearance to increase the demands on an affected area.
If a clinician has set restrictions, ask how the proposed activity and assessment fit those restrictions. A goal description does not replace that individual advice.
Pregnancy, a recent joint replacement, a heart condition, uncontrolled blood pressure or a history of cardiac events should be part of that conversation before a meaningful training change. The examples here supply no starting dose, clearance decision or return-to-training timetable.
Use a practice-and-assessment worksheet
Use the following questions when discussing a proposed plan or reading a training claim. This is a description worksheet, rather than a weekly programme or a recommendation to perform a test.
- Goal: What task or outcome matters outside the assessment?
- Practice: What activity was actually practised, and what was its stated purpose?
- Assessment: What task produced the reported number, using which units and denominator?
- Comparison: Which conditions match, which differ and which were not recorded?
- Inference: What does this result describe, and what would require another observation or a different study?
Leaving an answer unknown is more useful than filling it with an assumption. A blank about equipment, distance or assistance identifies the missing information without inventing a correction factor.
If you want help translating a personal goal into an appropriate plan, our guide to choosing a personal trainer covers questions to ask. Keep the intended purpose of an activity separate from an outcome that has actually been measured.
Video context
References
Kraemer, W. J., & Ratamess, N. A. (2004). Fundamentals of resistance training: Progression and exercise prescription. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 36(4), 674-688. https://doi.org/10.1249/01.mss.0000121945.36635.61
Reilly, T., Morris, T., & Whyte, G. (2009). The specificity of training prescription and physiological assessment: A review. Journal of Sports Sciences, 27(6), 575-589. https://doi.org/10.1080/02640410902729741
This article is for general information only and is not medical advice. If you have an injury, ongoing pain, or a medical condition, talk to a doctor or physical therapist before you change how you train or eat.





