physical fitness articles and diet tips blog
spring sale on exercise equipment

by WorkoutHealthy  on July 17, 2012Comments(2)

Tai Chi vs. Yoga vs. Pilates

A young woman exercising at the beach

Tai chi, yoga, and Pilates are three distinct approaches for bodily development belonging to the same “family”: calisthenics. Today, we use the word “calisthenics” – from the Greek “kalos” meaning “beautiful” and “sthenos” meaning “strength” – to broadly refer to light, free-body exercises and stretches designed to increase muscular tone and stamina, improve balance, flexibility and agility, and promote overall physical well-being and grace using one’s own bodyweight for resistance. While calisthenics were the ancient series of drills for soldiers ofGreece, self-defense activity and exercise predicated around bodily control developed across the globe and fromChinaandIndia, Tai Chi and Yoga sprang, respectively.

Fitness enthusiasts have developed these drills further into a variety of forms – like modern gymnastics – that still do not use additional weights or machines though may require some sort of apparatus or structure to lean on or from which to hang or suspend the body. The highly technical and energetic discipline of parkour is another 20th century development fromFrance. Pilates, for instance, another relative newcomer, developed inGermany.

While gymnastics and parkour are highly demanding athletic pursuits, the more accommodating tai chi, yoga, and Pilates have become popular forms of calisthenics as exercise for those with non-military and non-competitive interests and affiliation. Tai chi and yoga appeal further as artistic forms with a meditative or spiritual element.

Tai Chi

Like calisthenics of Greece, tai chi has a martial history. Tai chi, unlike some other martial arts, emphasizes relaxation as opposed to tension. The use of leverage through the joints demands coordination and fluidity to neutralize an attacker. Old-school tai chi training has five parts:

  1. Breathing and meditation
  2. Response drills
  3. Self defense (Sanshou)
  4. Weapons
  5. Forms (solo hand routines)

New school tai chi is more of a set of exercises and has led to some abandonment of uniforms and weapons. It’s common for teachers to lead a class of students in typical gym attire: loose, comfortable clothing and flat-soled or slipper-like footwear. The exercise is characterized by scores of slow, repetitive movements and static holds. The objective is to learn how to create leverage gently.

Despite its gentleness, this is not a cheese puff workout! Aside from toning and hardening your musculature, tai chi is famed for improvements to balance, circulation, breathing habits, and digestion. The meditative aspect is beneficial for stress reduction.

Yoga

Yoga comes from the school of Hinduphilosophy concerned with meditation toward the attainment of salvation. In the traditional sense, the religious implications of yoga are as profound as the physical. Religious discipline undoubtedly contributes to yoga’s worth in physically conditioning the body.

For those interested in yoga predominantly as a form of exercise, the focus is on “asanas,” i.e., postures. The basic approach is to attempt to transition from one static posture to another, emphasizing proper alignment and execution, hold each posture for a time – like stretching, to simplify. Important, though usually playing a lesser part in “pop yoga,” are breathing and meditation.

Dedicated yoga practitioners experience gradually improved flexibility, balance, and strength. Like tai chi, yoga involves mind-body connections meant to reduce stress as well as control pain and anxiety. Yoga has been shown in studies and in anecdotal accounts to have a number of benefits, from reducing high blood pressure to reducing symptoms of asthma to raising mental acuity.

Pilates

Perceiving a mental-physical connection, German physical-culturist Joseph Pilates developed this “medical gymnastics” system of corrective exercises to strengthen the human mind and body. Pilates, as it came to be known, builds, on account of the full range of motion and body weight reliance, flexibility and long, lean muscles, strength and endurance, particularly in the body’s core: abdominals, hips, and back. The movements emphasize spinal and pelvic alignment. Exercises are modified to control difficulty and intensity.

Like tai chi and yoga, conscious breathing is meant to relieve stress. Breathing techniques also help oxygen flow to muscles and play a part in developing a strong core.

The Common Connection

Physically, tai chi, yoga, and Pilates put a lot of emphasis on the “core.” In referring to the core, it means the following:

  1. The body’s core musculature; this describes unified and robust musculature for the entire body. Core musculature considers balanced development of large muscles – like the pectoralis – as well as deeper, smaller, supporting muscles – like those of the rotator cuff.
  2. The individual’s core strength; this is baseline, basic, or essential strength throughout the body. Core strength suggests coordination, stability, control, and power.
  3. The core region of the human body; this is the musculature of the abdomen, i.e., mostly the stomach, waist, and lower back, but also hips. Muscles of the core (i.e., the rectus abdominis, obliques, transverse abdominis, and erector spinae) support the spine and stabilize the torso.

Exercises for the core region of the human body involve spine-articulating exercises that will affect core musculature and contribute to core strength. In other words, a weak lower back will be a hindrance to realizing a unified and robust musculature for the entire body and be a hole in the body’s essential strength.

These three calisthenics forms will develop core musculature by training the entire body with basic movements. They build core strength by challenging practitioners to control fully and finely their own bodyweight. Through emphasis of the core region, they help an individual to become more “sure footed,” mindful of their body and gradually more aware of the component actions that must blend smoothly into complex physical acts. They also promote improved flexibility and mobility by progressively taking the major joints through a full, controlled range of motion. All three promote good coordination, balance, and flexibility.

The benefits of tai chi, yoga, and Pilates all depend on disciplined execution and attention to detail. At the end of the day, a practitioner of tai chi, toga, or Pilates will probably have a very similar visual appearance: slim and with taut muscles. Their performance will show an impressive degree of flexibility with excellent balance. Which to choose? It’s mostly your personal preference.

About the Author
Michael Chapdelaine is a professional writer and a drug free, health-conscious athlete. He is both an equipped and a raw powerlifter who has competed in the American Powerlifting Federation (APF), United States Powerlifting Federation (USPF), and with USA Powerlifting (USAPL). Michael has qualified for and competed in national and international events such as the 2010 Raw Nationals, the 2011 Arnold Raw Challenge, and the 2011 State Games of America.

FB Comments

comments

Comments

2 Responses to “Tai Chi vs. Yoga vs. Pilates”
  1. I have been doing P90X and one of the workouts is Yoga. Do you recommend mixing up your workout routine with core training like Tai Cheng or Yoga?

    • Shape-Up Shawn says:

      Hello Bryan,

      Yes you should always mix-up the type of workouts you are doing. The change provides your muscles with the “shock” factor that P90X preaches; so that you are always working different muscles and the same muscles in different ways.

Speak Your Mind


Further Reading: